Alek Shrader and Daniela Mack as Berlioz’s titular sparring lovers. Photo by Jacob Lucas

Alek Shrader and Daniela Mack as Berlioz’s titular sparring lovers. Photo by Jacob Lucas

The Merry War of ‘Beatrice and Benedict’ Shines Thanks to Clever Doctoring

Seattle Opera goes back to Shakespeare and enriches a slender but sparkling composition.

Once the afterglow of Seattle Opera’s adorable Beatrice and Benedict has died down, you may be left, as I was, with a troubling question: Why isn’t Hector Berlioz’s comedy in the standard repertory? There’s more musical interest in any six bars of Berlioz’s 1862 score than in an entire Donizetti comedy, which are ubiquitous on the world’s opera stages. Seattle Opera’s skillful script-doctoring of what is admittedly a fairly slender piece may help it gain a foothold. Generally, I’m not a fan of tinkering with a score, but when the solution is to add rather than subtract, it’s hard to complain.

From his source play, Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing, Berlioz retained only the main story thread, the two title characters who “never meet but there’s a skirmish of wit between them.” (The opera is part of the citywide Seattle Celebrates Shakespeare program.) Director John Langs and conductor Ludovic Morlot fleshed out a subplot with another pair of lovers, Claudio and Hero, borrowing from Shakespeare a scene in which Claudio is tricked into believing Hero unfaithful (which makes a affectingly bittersweet Act 1 curtain) and their later confrontation at what would have been their wedding. (The villain behind this deception, Don Juan, is included too as a non-singing part, and Brandon O’Neill makes him richly hissable.) A little music is added as well, all Berlioz, most notably a dramatic aria for Claudio (from his earlier opera Benvenuto Cellini). Shakespeare’s song “Sigh No More, Ladies” is cleverly set to the music of a brief aria from The Damnation of Faust and given to Somarone, the village music master. One short choral number is the third addition; a couple of the arias are slightly repositioned; and much of the spoken dialogue between the musical numbers comes straight from Shakespeare rather than from Berlioz’s adaptation of it. All this clocks in at about two hours; Berlioz’s original version must be barely 90 minutes, if that.

This is Seattle Opera’s third consecutive comedy of the season, and the contrast to the effortful Barber of Seville and Cosi fan tutte is like night and day—a sunshine-drenched day in Italy, to be exact. Langs and Morlot did a masterful job of making a full meal out of Berlioz’s tasty hors d’oeuvres, preserving the dash and insouciance of the original; the added pathos and drama enrich it without cluttering it. Not all opera singers are comfortable with spoken dialogue—with straight acting—and the four principals especially deserve a lot of credit for making even the longest musicless scenes work: Craig Verm as Claudio, Shelly Traverse as Hero (replacing Laura Tatulescu for the rest of the run due to illness), Daniela Mack as Beatrice, and Alek Shrader as Benedict. Shrader is, refreshingly, charming throughout; in the era of #MeToo, it’s a relief to see this production avoid the misogynist trope of making the heroine inexplicably fall for a jerk.

Matthew Smucker’s multi-level set, all bridges and spiral staircases, is as light as lacework; Deborah Trout’s costumes splash color everywhere. Langs has a fantastic eye for simple yet powerful scenic effects; I won’t spoil the surprise of what happens at the thwarted wedding. The best sight gag comes during Hero’s luscious Act 1 aria, interrupted at the end by a regiment of soldiers jogging past, ending in a gallant gesture from Claudio. Dramaturgically, everything works; technically, only about 50 percent of the spoken words overall come through, and the blame should be divided between the sound system (the singers are miked, we’re told, only for their dialogue) and, unavoidably, McCaw Hall’s resonance (it was designed wet for music, not dry for theater). Maybe a little can go to the actors; some of them do talk fast. You may end up hoping that the spoken passages as well as the sung ones would be supertitled.

Beatrice and Benedict

Feb. 28 & March 3, 7, 9, & 10 at 7:30 p.m., McCaw Hall, $61–$199, seattleopera.org.

gborchert@seattleweekly.com

More in Arts & Culture

Cat Power (aka Chan Marshall). Photo by Julien Bourgeois
Cat Power Powers Through

The acclaimed singer-songwriter chats about her stripped-down new album ‘Wanderer,’ motherhood, and when performance gets in the way of the song.

Sloucher displaying surprisingly decent posture. Photo by Eleanor Petry
Sloucher Is Not Posturing

The Seattle band doesn’t shy away from embracing ’90s guitar rock on ‘Be True.’

Rhino riggers protest outside of the Jay-Z and Beyonce show outside of Seattle’s CenturyLink Field on Oct. 4, 2018. Photo courtesy of IATSE
The Backstage Blues: Riggers Complain of Unfair Labor Practices

Theatrical stage employees come for the music and stay for the thrill. But at what price?

Viola Davis and Cynthia Erivo star in ‘Widows.’ Photo by Merrick Morton
Crime Doesn’t Pay Off in ‘Widows’

Steve McQueen’s feminist heist thriller stretches itself far too thin.

Tim Blake Nelson plays the titular Buster Scruggs. Photo courtesy Netflix
‘The Ballad of Buster Scruggs’ Is a Wagon Train of Dark Mischief

The Coen brothers’ new anthology seves as a glorious ode to Westerns’ dusty death.

City Arts Ceases Publication

The free local culture magazine shuts down operations after 12 years.

Greta Klein (center right) brings the soft indie pop Frankie Cosmos to The Neptune. Photo by Angel Ceballos
The Soft Comfort of Frankie Cosmos

Sub Pop’s tenderest band brings its indie pop to The Neptune.

French dance company Compagnie Käfig brings the lights of ‘Pixel’ to Meany Center. Photo by Laurent Philippe
Pick List: Compagnie Käfig, Brooklyn Rider, Pete Souza

The week’s best entertainment offerings.

Most Read