Killer Logic

Feds say no, but their own findings give reason to list local orcas as endangered.

JUST LIKE CLOCKWORK, and just before the deadline tolled, a coalition of seven conservation groups, plus that indefatigable whale hugger Ralph Munro, filed suit last Wednesday to force the federal government to recognize Washington’s resident killer whales as a distinct, endangered population under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). The lawsuit had been expected since last June, when the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS)—contrary to the implications of its own scientific findings, but in keeping with conventional scientific wisdom and current political trends— refused to recognize southern resident orcas as a “significant” population meriting ESA protection.

The Fisheries Service instead proposed listing them as a “depleted” population under the narrower protection of the Marine Mammal Protection Act. NMFS spokesperson Brian Gorman insists the difference is one of “process, not goal. . . . We care very much about protecting this population.” Gorman notes that the marine mammal act has the same “anti- harassment provisions” as the ESA. But that’s hardly the only or worst threat. Endangered-species status would require that governments and businesses protect not just individual whales but their habitat—a powerful and potentially expensive lever to force Puget Sound cleanup, if long-lived, toxin-accumulating orcas can be shown to need cleaner waters than the salmon species that are already protected.

So why don’t the southern orcas qualify? Gorman vehemently denies any political pressure: “I can state categorically that doesn’t happen. This is a result of recommendations of our own scientific panel.” And no one denies that the local killer whales are imperiled: Despite long natural life spans, their numbers have fallen by nearly a fifth since 1996, while infant mortality and PCB contamination have soared. The question is how “distinct” they are.

Official taxonomy classifies all killer whales around the globe as a single species, Orcinus orca. But as Gorman himself notes, that’s “an outmoded view that ought be changed.” Last April, NMFS’s own biological review team spelled out ample reason to consider the resident orcas a distinct population, perhaps even a separate species. Fish-eating resident whales and the transient orcas that range along the coast and eat mammals look different, have different social structures, and don’t noticeably interact.

Even other resident orcas to the north rarely enter local waters and don’t interbreed. Individual “cultures”—the knowledge of local geography, food cycles, climate, etc.—might be as important to orcas as to humans. For all these reasons, NMFS biologists concluded, “the prospect of recolonization . . . may be remote.” In other words, if we let these whales die out, orcas may never swim here again.

The plaintiffs will doubtless throw all these findings back at the feds in court.

escigliano@seattleweekly.com


Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@seattleweekly.com.

More in News & Comment

File photo
WA lawmakers propose making companies responsible for recycling improvements

SB 5697 would compel industries to report data, invest in infrastructure, meet standards.

Governor Jay Inslee. Sound Publishing file photo
Inslee: Officials’ lies about election results should be crime

Governor wants lawmakers to pass legislation making it a gross misdemeanor.

State Sen. Jesse Salomon
Shoreline senator’s bill would close loophole on police disciplinary actions

Jesse Salomon says Kent Police assistant chief case example of why changes are needed

File photo
County auditor finds agencies fall short on emergency services

The auditor’s office recommends clarifying responsibilities and accountability for effective planning.

File photo.
COVID testing centers shut down for lack of business license

Center for Covid Control announced Jan. 13 it would close all of its locations for a week.

During a news conference Thursday, Washington Gov. Jay Inslee explains the deployment of the National Guard to hospitals to assist with the coronavirus surge. (TVW) 20220113
Surgeries paused, National Guard deployed to assist hospitals

King County health officials say 1 in 7 ICU and acute-care hospital beds are occupied by a COVID patient.

Credit: Pixabay
Prosecutor alleges Seattle man recorded Muckleshoot Casino employee using toilet

The Auburn Police Department reports that a Seattle man used his cell… Continue reading

Screenshot from City of Kent Facebook Page
Trash piles up in King County neighborhoods after agency postpones service for weeks

Collection company initially cited weather as the reason, but now a strike interferes.

Most Read