Students Pitch Budget Cuts to Gregoire

Their message: Cut your friends, not our schools.

Facing a $9 billion state budget deficit, Gov. Chris Gregoire and the state legislature claim they’re looking everywhere to make cuts. But Alex Ng, Ricky Tran, Jennifer Truong, and Joann Ucol, students in Miriam Miller’s 10th Grade Law & Society/History & Humanities classes at Franklin High School, think state officials ought to look under their long noses. Rather than, say, cutting housing, education, and medical benefits to the poor, how about removing some of those multimillion-dollar tax breaks for Boeing, Microsoft, and other corpulent cats?

Miller’s students put together a PowerPoint presentation, using figures from a Seattle Weekly story (“$64 Billion Falls Through the Tax Cracks,” Feb. 18, 2004), detailing 503 tax exemptions worth $64 billion in givebacks to individuals and industry. The presentation asked why, for one, Washington schools could be so underfunded when the repeal of just a few select tax breaks could remedy that shortage? “I sent the PowerPoint to [House speaker] Frank Chopp, [then–King County exec] Ron Sims, the presidents of the various bar associations, and so on,” says Miller. “And there was no response.”

That’s likely because no one wants to talk about erasing tax exemptions that, rather than being reversed, have steadily been expanded by state lawmakers. Today, “tax preference items,” as the state Department of Revenue (DOR) calls them in its 2008 exemptions report, number 567 and total $98.5 billion—up more than $34 billion from four years ago. They include, for example, the more than $4 billion in tax breaks for Boeing to smaller exemptions handed out to myriad businesses—grocers, caterers, farmers, and brewers, to name a few.

Typically, those are exemptions recipients obtained by lobbying the governor and legislature, claiming the breaks were needed to profit and survive. But while many exemptions are necessary and commonplace—property-tax breaks, for example—DOR director Cindi Holmstrom says her staff has identified a series of exemptions that, if eliminated, could bring $15 billion into state coffers. They include reversing exemptions on some aerospace, high-tech, biotech, agriculture, newspaper, vehicle, fruit-processing, fuel, tobacco, and beverage products and processes—all detailed in a 330-page report on DOR’s website.

A state commission is also reviewing the exemptions, notes DOR spokesperson Mike Gowrylow. But it has made little headway. The breaks aren’t a sexy topic, nor easily understood. Miller’s class realized that, and in their presentation suggested the answer might be a state income tax. But as the kids put it, “The people of the State of Washington have no will to change the tax system.”

More in News & Comment

Washington Low Income Housing Alliance is among supporters of statewide “just cause” legislation to protect tenants in Washington. However, some landlords say removing the ability to quickly remove tenants limits their ability to get rid of problem renters. (Courtesy image)
Tenant advocates prepare for another push in Olympia

Following wins in Burien and Federal Way, just cause evictions are on the 2020 Legislative agenda.

Business alliance serves women of African diaspora in King County

Nourah Yonous launched the African Women Business Alliance in 2017 to find ways to lift women up.

Fire along Twisp River Road in the Okanogan Wenatchee National Forest in 2018. Courtesy photo
Wildfire response: State unveils funding legislation proposal

Last year, Department of Natural Resources responded to record number of wildfires.

A new report, complete with recommendations to the Legislature, has been released by a statewide task force that was formed to address a lack of child care in Washington. File photo
Report outlines lack of child care in Washington

In King County, supply doesn’t meet demand for child care.

You’ve been hacked! Data breaches in Washington on the rise

But fewer people had personal information compromised from cyberattacks in 2019 compared to 2018.

Demonstrators from La Resistencia protest Amazon’s involvement with ICE. Photo courtesy of La Resistencia
How will the U.S. respond to climate refugees?

Business as usual has been harder borders, are there other ways to address climate migration?

Safe drug consumption sites have been recommended by the King County Heroin and Opioid Task Force. Pictured is a safe consumption site in Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada. Photo supplied by ARCHES in Lethbridge
What’s been happening with safe injection sites?

There hasn’t been much coverage this year compared to the last couple years.

File photo of a pothole
King County approves roads, bridges funding

The capital projects funding is significantly less than previous years.

Turkeys Nonni, Noelle, November and Nora at Rooster Haus Rescue in Fall City. Natalie DeFord/staff photo
Turkey’s not on the Thanksgiving menu with this group

Rooster Haus Rescue provides a home for turkeys, chickens, roosters, cats, dogs, ducks and peacocks.

Most Read