Pocket Docket

The State Supreme Court says the bulge was searched illegally.

Can an apparently law-abiding citizen, walking along a city street, be arrested for having a bulge in his pants? Yes—in Richland, anyway.

It happened to Dustin Warren Harrington around 11 p.m. on Aug. 13, 2005. Police Officer Scott Reiber thought Harrington looked suspicious walking through a neighborhood at night. He then flipped a U-turn and asked Harrington if they could talk.

Reiber asked Harrington where he was coming from. His sister’s house, Harrington said, but he didn’t know exactly where the house was. That made Reiber suspicious, and Harrington seemed nervous, according to court records.

The officer then noticed bulges in Harrington’s pockets. Reiber also thought it suspicious that Harrington kept moving his hands in and out of them. As a state trooper pulled up to assist, the cop asked if he could pat down Harrington for officer safety, explaining that he was not under arrest.

Harrington agreed. Reiber then “felt a hard, cylindrical object in Harrington’s front right pocket,” according to the record.

“What’s this?” asked the cop.

“My glass,” said Harrington. “My meth pipe.”

Harrington, also carrying a baggie of meth, was arrested immediately and later convicted of unlawful possession of a controlled substance. He appealed, claiming the evidence was seized illegally.

Last week, the state Supreme Court unanimously agreed. “We conclude,” said Justice Richard Sanders, who authored the prevailing opinion, “the officers’ actions [i.e., Officer Reiber and the assisting trooper], when viewed cumulatively, impermissibly disturbed Harrington’s private affairs without authority of law and therefore constituted an unlawful seizure.”

Asking someone if you can pat down their body, writes Sanders, “is inconsistent with a mere social contact. If Reiber felt jittery about the bulges in Harrington’s pockets, he should have terminated the encounter—which Reiber initiated—and walked back to his patrol car…When Reiber requested a frisk, the officers’ series of actions matured into a progressive intrusion substantial enough to seize [control of] Harrington…Our [state] constitution protects against disturbance of private affairs—a broad concept that encapsulates searches and seizures…Article I, section 7 cannot tolerate the officers’ progressive intrusion into Harrington’s privacy.”

More in News & Comment

Despite Supreme Court Ruling, Activists Fight Youth Incarceration

No New Youth Jail Coalition members send Valentines to King County officials asking them to reconsider funding priorities

Tukwila Businesses Face Uncertain Future With Arrival Of Justice Center

Immigrant communities in Tukwila and SeaTac are under pressure.

Andy Bronson / The Herald 
                                Southbound traffic backs up as northbound drivers cruise on with ease on the Highway 99 viaduct on Tuesday, January 8.
WSDOT Hopes ‘Viadoom’ Habits Continue

The department credits commuters with adapting to the closure and mitigating impacts.

President’s Emergency Declaration Sparks Immediate Legal Backlash

Attorney General Bob Ferguson said his team will sue the White House if federal funds originally intended for Washington state are interrupted.

Bill Targets Sexual Health Curriculum in Washington Schools

Senate Bill 5395 is co-sponsored by 17 Democratic representatives and introduced by Sen. Claire Wilson, D-Federal Way.

According to King County’s Mental Illness and Drug Dependency (MIDD) annual report, Seattle had the highest rate of people using services at 36 percent of the total, followed by 31 percent from South King County, 18 percent from the greater Eastside, and 7 percent from north county including Shoreline.
Study Shows King County’s Treatment Funding Is Making Progress

A document on the county’s .1 percent health sales tax was accepted Wednesday by the county council.

Children’s play area at Seadrunar. Photo by Lauren Davis via Facebook
The Seedy Side of Seadrunar

Public records reveal that Seattle drug rehab center was accused of neglecting children and clients in its care.

Somali Community Faces SeaTac Displacement

Proposed redevelopment threatens the heart of the Somali business community.

14.1 Inches And Counting: Record-Breaking Snow Pounds King County

Several winter storms passed through the region, dumping more than 14 inches of snow.

Most Read