No Standing Against Vets

Pet owners find they have no legal standing to get their vet disciplined.

Des Moines couple Kenneth and Nonna Newman really loved their dog. When Trali, a Pekingese, developed a herniated disc in 2006, they spent thousands of dollars on MRIs and surgery, according to their attorney, Adam Karp.

Two veterinarians eventually persuaded Nonna that “if she really loved her dog enough, she would consent to euthanasia,” as the Newmans recall in legal documents. The Newmans complied, but later received information that led them to believe that Trali could have been successfully treated and didn’t need to be put to sleep. They filed a complaint with the state’s Veterinary Board of Governors. When the board declined to discipline the vets involved, the Newmans took the matter to court. Last week, the state Court of Appeals ruled that the couple wasn’t entitled to any kind of judicial review.

Karp says the ruling will apply to decisions involving all health professionals—doctors, nurses, psychologists, massage therapists. The judges are saying that it’s up to the state boards and commissions that govern these professions to decide whether discipline is warranted. And if patients (or their owners) don’t like the state’s decisions, there is, in Karp’s words, “nothing you can do about it.” (Though, of course, wronged patients can still sue for malpractice on their own behalf.)

The court ruled that the Newmans didn’t have legal “standing,” in part because they could not prove that they had been injured by the state’s decision not to discipline the vets.

Rather, the court noted, it is license holders—vets, doctors, and so on—who have standing to question disciplinary decisions because they are at risk of losing their livelihoods.

Nonna, who works as a contract bargainer for the SEIU, says the ruling made her feel as though “Trali was killed all over again.” She and her husband, a seafood executive, are considering whether to appeal to the state Supreme Court.

Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing

More in News & Comment

The Monroe Correctional Complex on April 9, 2020. (Sound Publishing file photo)
Formerly incarcerated people regain right to vote in Washington

Rights restored immediately upon release.

Puget Sound renters will need housing assistance
Puget Sound renters will need housing assistance

Nonprofits, activists are expecting greater need as workers are laid off.

Spring Chinook Salmon. Photo courtesy Michael Humling, US Fish & Wildlife Service
Salmon update: King County wants cleaner water, more habitat

Salmon and orcas are in the spotlight once again as King County… Continue reading

Guns seized during April 7 arrests (photo credit: Dept. of Justice)
More than 20 arrested across the Puget Sound in drug distribution conspiracy

DOJ says law enforcement agencies seized over 70 guns and hundreds of thousands in cash.

Sheriff’s office wants help identifying Green River killer victim

Staff reports In 2003, Gary Ridgway, Washington’s notorious Green River killer, pleaded… Continue reading

King County Prosecutor Dan Satterberg. File photo
King County needs more lawyers to attack backlog of cases

6,107 open cases is double the normal amount for King County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office.

Public Health – Seattle & King County staff administering COVID-19 vaccine to a local emergency responder. COURTESY PHOTO, Public Health-Seattle & King County
Starting April 15, everyone 16 and older is eligible for a vaccine

Gov. Inslee said an expected increase in vaccine supply enables the state to open eligibility.

A CVS pharmacist prepares a COVID-19 vaccine at Village Green Retirement Campus in Federal Way on Jan. 26. Olivia Sullivan/Sound Publishing
Phase Finder for vaccine eligibility to be eliminated March 31

Eligibility verification via Phase Finder no longer required for appointments, vaccinations beginning this week.

Courtesy photo
Issaquah School District settles negligence lawsuit for $4.25 million

The lawsuit alleged the district covered for a now-convicted child molester while he was a teacher.

Most Read