Love Letters

A seemingly innocuous proposal to cut down on junk mail has the state's rural carriers going postal.

Love Letters

Like the leaves that clog ourgutters every fall, or the grass that never stops growing, junk mail is an extension of nature that requires constant pruning. Most of us have become so attuned to the daily promises of cheaper cable service and low fixed APRs that we can fling most mass mailers into the trash with nary a fear of discarding something vital.

But state legislators are questioning whether AOL disks and pizza coupons should be included in our daily mail-fetching routine at all: Last Thursday, Sen. Jeanne Kohl-Welles, D-Seattle, urged her fellow lawmakers at a Senate Consumer Protection and Housing Committee hearing to pass a law creating a “Do Not Mail” registry. The state-maintained database–which would be the first in the nation–would allow residents to opt out ofreceiving all junk mail. Any business that advertises through the mail to Washing-tonians would have to put systems into place to keep the right people out of the loop.

As the bill stands, violators would face a $2,000 fine per offense. Only charities, political campaigns, and organizations that have existing relationships with clients would be allowed to send direct mail to people on the list.

“It gives individuals the opportunity to [opt out] who are very disturbed about the amount of mail that they think is junk mail,” says Kohl-Welles.

Last fall, the Maryland-based Center for a New American Dream asked one of its Seattle contacts, Brad Hole, to lead an effort to purge Washington of unwanted bulk mail. Hole, a Ballard resident who runs an enviro-friendly office supply business, agreed to rally legislative support for the Maryland group’s cause.

“I didn’t know much about it going into it,” says Hole. “I get junk mail like everybody else. It’s a pain.”

New American Dream failed to get similar measures passed last year in Missouri, Illinois, and New York. All three died in committee. This year, in addition to Missouri and Washington, they’re working on legislation in Colorado, Maryland, Michigan, and Texas.

At Thursday’s hearing, Kohl-Welles rattled off some statistics that she thinks prove how diabolical junk mail is: hundreds of millions of dollars spent per year to dispose of mail that doesn’t get recycled; California spending $500,000 per year to pitch the aforementioned AOL disks; a National Park’s worth of trees every four months stuffed into American mailboxes in the form of QFC circulars and Bed Bath & Beyond coupons.

It’s tough to argue with the logic of Kohl-Welles’ bill, except when you consider what’s at stake for the opposition: jobs, as well as significant salary reductions for rural mail carriers. “We depend on bulk business mail,” says PatriciaAlexander, president of the Washington Rural Letter Carriers Association, which has about 2,000 members in the state.

Alexander, who delivers mail to 700 customers on the Lummi Indian Reservation near the Canadian border, worries that she could be forced to take a pay cut of up to $10,000 per year if the registry went into effect. That’s because rural carriers, unlike their metropolitan counterparts, get paid based on volume rather than the number of hours they work. Every year, an alternating sample of two or four weeks is conducted to count the number of pieces delivered on each route, determining the salary for the following year; the greater the number, the higher the salary. So for folks like Alexander, opposition to a Do Not Mail list is a no-brainer.

Kohl-Welles says that it “would absolutely be the case” that the bill will haveto be changed in order to accommodatethe needs of labor. “It puts me in a real dilemma,” she acknowledges. “You can’t go forward with environmental issues because of concerns…you have to balance.”

Alexander’s husband, Charles, also a rural carrier and state steward for the rural carriers’ union, says that the registry would also create needless headaches that would drive up mail rates. “The postal service would be in a situation where they’ll likely have to pay more to deliver something they’re receiving less revenue on,” he says.

Flyers that don’t carry specific addresses are cheap for businesses to send out because they don’t have to be sorted by destination; the carrier just has to drop one in each box. But if Kohl-Welles’ law is enacted as written, carriers could have to bring a list of all the people on their routes who opted out of receiving the flyers. Or perhaps the flyer classification would be eliminated altogether, necessitating that all pieces of mail be addressed and sorted, thus raising rates for businesses.

But therein lies an interesting twist: Rural carriers’ pay is also determined by how much they handle the mail. The more processing that’s involved, the more money they get.

“Their concern is they’re going to run out of work as a result of this, right?” says attorney Dan Fiorito, who testified alongside Hole before the Senate Consumer Protection and Housing Committee. “Well, that might make them actually do more work.”

Fiorito, also a Ballard resident and a close friend of Hole’s, says it would be up to the state attorney general to determine if companies doing blanket mailings were violating the statute. But if such mailings weren’t prohibited, it would leave the law with a loophole big enough to drive a logging truck through, cutting off its purpose at the roots.

A Feb. 2 e-mail sent to Jacob White, counsel for the Senate consumer protection committee, from Steve Larsen at the attorney general’s office outlines several scenarios that would undermine the proposed law: the exemption for pre-existing business-client relationships, offers such as sweepstakes that open people up to being marketed to, and federally regulated credit card offers that he says the state cannot interdict.

“There are just too many ways that the mail will get there even if there is a do not mail list,” Larsen writes.

Steven Krieger, New American Dream’s grassroots coordinator and community liaison, says that database tools for the list will be able to solve most of these issues, before adding: “Let the consumers and direct mailers sort through this.”

Currently, the Direct Marketing Association, an industry group that represents about 4,000 U.S. companies, offers its own Do Not Mail list to consumers. “[The list] can reduce mail people get by up to 80 percent,” says DMA spokesperson Stephanie Hendricks.

On its Web site, DMA also lists a toll-free number for opting out of credit card offers. “There are a lot of options out there that aren’t ‘Stop sending me everything,'” Hendricks adds. “It could potentially hurt local businesses.”

But Hole argues that the state-run Do Not Mail list could save businesses money, as companies wouldn’t waste funds mailing to people who don’t want their products. Instead of sending out flyers to everyone, Hole urges businesses to “do a little research [and] get creative.”

The Direct Marketing Association testified against Do Not Mail at the Olympia hearing last week. No surprise there: DMA also fought against the federal government’s Do Not Call registry, a tool implemented in 2003 that allowed millions of Americans to sit down to dinner without being interrupted by telemarketers forthe first time in years. On this front, theIndianapolis-based American Teleservices Association says that the number of contact center employees in the U.S. is currently at 5.2 million–but if Do Not Call hadn’t been implemented, it would be around 6.5million. ATA also says that a quarter-million telemarketers were laid off “immediately” after Do Not Call went into effect.

“Citizens have the right to post a ‘No Soliciting’ sign on their doors, turn off the TV and radio when unwanted ads come on, and sign up for the popular Do Not Call telemarketer registry,” says a letter Hole sent to the Senate consumer protection committee chair, Brian Weinstein, D–Mercer Island. “Shouldn’t we have the right to opt out of junk mail with an easy-to-use Do Not Mail registry?”

But not everyone agrees that junk mail creates the same headaches as telemarketing calls. Drew Von Bergen, spokesperson for the National Association of Letter Carriers, the Washington, D.C.–based union for delivery workers, sums it up like this: “In telemarketing, they seem to annoy you when you’re sitting down to dinner. You don’t have to jump up in the middle of a meal and open up your mailbox.”

Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing

More in News & Comment

Photo of promotional recruitment banner used by Auburn Police Department at Petpalooza. The banner features Auburn Police Officer Jeff Nelson, who is awaiting trial for the 2019 murder and assault of Jesse Sarey. Photo courtesy of Jeff Trimble
Auburn police use photo of embattled officer on recruitment banner

Families of people killed by Jeffrey Nelson, who’s awaiting trial for murder, speak out over use of his photo at Petpalooza.

Use your King County library card to explore the outdoors

KCLS cardholders can check out a Discover Pass for two weeks to explore public lands.

Monkeypox virus. Photo courtesy of the Centers for Disease Control.
King County identifies first presumptive monkeypox case

The illness is not as easily transmitted compared to COVID-19, according to health officer.

This screenshot from Auburn Police Department bodycam footage shows an officer about to fire his weapon and kill dog on May 13, 2022.
Auburn police shoot dog, and owner claims it wasn’t justified

See videos of attack as well as bodycam footage of officer firing at dog.

File photo.
King County Council approves creation of Cannabis Safety Taskforce amid rash of dispensary robberies

The multi-agency task force will cooperate to find ways to improve safety in the cash-only industry.

Screenshot from ORCA website
New ORCA system launches for regional transit across the Puget Sound

Overhaul includes new website, mobile application and digital business account manager.

Judged by XII: A King County Local Dive podcast. The hands shown here belong to Auburn Police Officer Jeffrey Nelson, who has been charged with homicide in the 2019 death of Jesse Sarey.
JUDGED BY XII (Episode 4): Foster mom wants accountability in Auburn cop’s upcoming murder trial

Special podcast series explores Auburn Police Officer Jeffrey Nelson’s role in the death of Jesse Sarey.

Diane Renee Erdmann and Bernard Ross Hansen. Photos courtesy of FBI
FBI arrests Auburn couple after 11-day manhunt

The couple was previously convicted for fraud and skipped sentencing on April 29.

Screenshot from Barnes and Noble website
Cover art of books that KSD Librarian Gavin Downing says have been under fire: “Jack of Hearts (and Other Parts),” by Lev A.C. Rosen, “If I Was Your Girl,” by Meredith Russo, and “All Boys Aren’t Blue,” by George Matthew Johnson.
Kent middle school librarian wins intellectual freedom award

Gavin Downing refused to keep ‘silence in the library’ amid attempted book banning and censorship.

Kent elementary school teacher accused of using racist language toward student

River Ridge Elementary instructor placed on administrative leave by Kent School District.

FILE PHOTO: King County Sheriff’s Office deputies.
Dozens of King County Sheriff’s Office employees left jobs instead of getting vaccinated

This added on to the existing number of vacancies in the department.