Judging Aimless Killing

Some get hard time for fatal collisions, others get off easy.

IT’S A STORY to get a suspicious citizen’s blood boiling. A young woman, speeding in her Ford Explorer and, according to the State Patrol, talking on her cell phone, plows into a stalled Civic. The Civic’s gas tank ruptures and burns, and the car’s four occupants—a couple from Bulgaria and their young daughters—are killed. State troopers trace the woman’s cell phone records and find that, contrary to her claims, she was talking on the phone when she rammed the Civic. They recommend charging her with vehicular homicide. Instead, King County prosecutors last week decided not to charge Sarah Potts with any felony—leaving the State Patrol the option of pursuing second-degree negligent driving in District Court. That carries a top fine of $250.

Oh, one more thing. Potts is the wife of a Bothell police officer. Hah! you might say. Once again, the fraternity protects its own. A cop’s wife’s freedom is worth more than the lives of struggling immigrants and their children.

Not at all, King County prosecutors insist. “We looked for some type of evidence to bring a charge of vehicular homicide,” says prosecutors’ spokesperson Dan Donohoe. “There just wasn’t any. We were not able to show she was going at an extreme speed beyond the flow of traffic. With the cell phone, there would need to be some evidence that her driving was affected in some way, such as swerving.” Donohoe concedes that Potts “was negligent and inattentive.” But “inattention alone under these circumstances would not constitute disregard of the safety of others.”

Those may sound like fine hairs to split. But Paul Cullen, a defense attorney who’s handled many motor-vehicle cases, says this argument sounds consistent with past application of vehicular-homicide law. And King County prosecutors have gone after other public-safety figures who kill people in off-duty accidents much more aggressively. In 1999, they sought and won a vehicular-homicide conviction against George Moorhead, a Woodinville firefighter who rammed a car carrying three Vietnamese-born men—immigrants again. They also urged prison time—three years, the standard sentence. But the trial judge, citing Moorhead’s upstanding record, assigned a year on work release, to the prosecutors’ dismay. The factors were different then, says Donohoe. Not only was Moorhead, like Potts, driving “over the posted limit,” but he ran a stop sign and registered 0.07 percent blood alcohol an hour after the crash—enough to constitute willful disregard. The jury convicted him even though the judge suppressed that blood-alcohol data.

And then there was the Bellevue police officer, Eric Thomas, who prosecutors say was driving 80-plus in a 40-mph zone when he spun into an oncoming car. One of Thomas’s passengers died, and another, an off-duty state trooper, was disabled. Thomas’ timing was unlucky: Three hours earlier, the state’s new 0.08 blood-alcohol standard took effect. Thomas registered 0.08. The judge rejected a plea for leniency based on his “exemplary” police record and gave him three years in prison.

Of three drivers whose negligence caused death, the police officer got the hardest time. So much for favoritism.

We’ve all seen people driving and holding phones barrel through intersections in utter obliviousness. Perhaps you, too, have narrowly gotten out of their way. If the tragedy of Sarah Potts and the Attilas teaches us anything, it is that it’s time for a law against DWT—driving while telephoning.


Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@seattleweekly.com.

More in News & Comment

U.S. Sen. Patty Murray, D-WA, who pushed for broadband funding in Washington schools. (Screenshot from murray.senate.gov)
American Rescue Plan Act funding approved for broadband investments in WA schools

U.S. Sen. Patty Murray pushed for the funding, which will benefit several King County school districts.

Courtesy photo
State offers free at-home COVID-19 tests

You can order the tests through the state’s new online portal.

Sen. Mona Das, D-47
Kent Democratic Sen. Mona Das proposes 1% cut in state sales tax

Starting in 2023; Republicans voice support for Senate Bill 5932

Federal Way police arrest suspect in fatal carjacking

35-year-old Tacoma man charged with murder in “random, brutal and senseless carjacking,” prosecutors say.

File photo.
Man accused of fatally shooting 11-year-old girl’s dog in front of her

The defendant is being charged with first-degree animal cruelty and reckeless endangerment.

Stock photo, Metro Creative Graphics
Auburn, Federal Way mayors speak out against multifamily housing bill

Leaders say they don’t need state intervention.

File photo
Non-profit sponsors study on how the pandemic impacted arts and culture in Puget Sound

The study helped identify challenges faced by residents and cultural organizations in Washington

File photo
WA lawmakers propose making companies responsible for recycling improvements

SB 5697 would compel industries to report data, invest in infrastructure, meet standards.

Governor Jay Inslee. Sound Publishing file photo
Inslee: Officials’ lies about election results should be crime

Governor wants lawmakers to pass legislation making it a gross misdemeanor.

Most Read