Hearst to P-I: Drop Half-Dead?

The confusing hypocrisy of Steve Swartz's newsroom performance keeps Hearst's intentions a mystery.

Some Seattle Post-Intelligencer old-timers might remember an editor named Nard Jones who, after a day composing sober editorials on weighty civic issues, went to an open window in his office at the P-I‘s then-headquarters in the Regrade, pushed a three-foot stack of manila paper into the wind over Sixth Avenue, and ran tippy-toe through the newsroom exclaiming “It’s snowing, it’s snowing!” Fifty years ago, this was the newspaper whose social and moral codes regularly required newsroom artists to doctor photographs, using the white strokes of an airbrush to slim down the fat ankles of society matrons or remove the balls from a German shepherd—a smoky newsroom of sob sisters and boozers where copyboys were sent to the bar across the street to fetch lunch for sportswriters: highballs in milkshake cartons.

It was different after the P-I packed up its globe and moved to a new building on the waterfront in 1986. Newspapers were evolving—less fun, but more respectful work. No more would a beleaguered reporter likely need to drop acid to get through the day. (The one who did in the old P-I newsroom said the idea backfired: “I kept seeing two city editors!”) Staffers were less likely to be fired subtly—returning from vacation, as one did, to find his desk gone. Fewer reporters would have to learn how chickenshit the paper could be. I learned that as a reporter there in the ’70s, when I walked into the police press room one day and introduced myself to reporter George McDowell. “You’re my what?” he kept saying. Nobody had thought to call and tell him he was being replaced after 30 years.

Yet, with the days of Front Page journalism long faded, what was more ridiculous and chickenshit than that scene in the P-I‘s Elliott Avenue newsroom last Friday? There in white shirt and tie was the paper’s undertaker, Steve Swartz, a president of Hearst Corp., telling a hushed staff that the 146-year-old P-I, and their jobs, had 60 days before he would begin burying them. The paper would be offered for sale, and if nobody bit, “we will have to pursue other options.” One was an all-digital operation of the P-I, he said. Another was a complete shutdown.

He was writing the P-I‘s own obituary. Or so it seemed. Straight answers—any answers—weren’t forthcoming. He stood with his arms folded and told the crowd of reporters and editors he had no further information about the plane crash they’d just experienced. “This is the beginning of the process,” Swartz said. “I can’t tell you what is going to happen, so I don’t think it’s appropriate to engage in speculation or a series of what-ifs. So I will not be taking questions at this time.”

Head of Hearst’s newspaper division for all of one month, Swartz revealed just how little he knew about how these places operate. Nothing makes their workers more willing to engage in speculation than a “no comment,” especially when followed by some confusing hypocrisy: The paper wasn’t good enough to publish anymore, but Swartz couldn’t contain his praise for it. “This is a great newspaper. The front pages you produce every day are lively and vibrant, and I like to think [founder] W. R. Hearst would be proud.” He lauded the investigative reporting, editorial pages, and columnists. But journalism is a business, he added. Losses are escalating—supposedly $14 million last year, though Hearst won’t open its books to prove it. The end is near, Swartz said, and “I will be back in touch [with] you at the appropriate time.”

The media reports that followed left the impression the P-I is dead. But the headline should read: Hearst to P-I: Drop Half-Dead. The point most discernible is that the newspaper will stop being a paper, though Swartz hedged even that: “We do not see ourselves publishing the P-I in printed form” after 60 days, he said. Well, does he see someone else publishing it? The conventional wisdom is that, as print media collapse beneath the weight of the Internet, no one will buy something that requires ink. But would anyone take it for free? That’s essentially what happened after Hearst bought the San Francisco Chronicle: In 2000, it handed over its former flagship SF Examiner along with its archives, 35 delivery trucks, and a $66 million subsidy, to the Fang family—in return for $100 cash. (The Fangs turned the Ex into a lively free tab, then sold it off). [This story has been corrected since it was first posted. It originally said that the Examiner had become online-only.]

And half-dead is still alive. The P-I has officially been a failing newspaper since the 1980s—when it struck a Joint Operating Agreement with the Times to have its paper published, marketed, and delivered by its rival. The likelihood in recent years that it would end up online-only has been seen not as a death but as a rebirth. Should anyone be too surprised the paper may finally be fulfilling its e-destiny? Swartz’s silence leaves a gap in understanding why a Web-only P-I is a viable alternative. Some think he had to dance around that point because of unsettled JOA issues with the Times (for example, will a merely electronic edition still be able to share ad revenue under the JOA?).

The Times faces a similar decision on keeping or revising its costly, shrinking print edition. But down the road the two papers could both live on, perhaps in a kind of electronic JOA, competing for news while continuing to share ads and their libraries. Hearst also could go it alone with some online variation—a mega–Web site fed by the P-I and e-content from its other papers. Either way, there’s no compelling reason for Hearst to dump the prized Seattle site.

Of course, it still means lots of newsroom goodbyes. Even living on as an e-paper, the P-I would cut as much as two-thirds of its 170 staffers, and likely retire its globe to a museum. That’s a heartbreak, and remindful of the scene that late P-I reporter John J. O’Ryan used to describe when the Seattle Star folded in 1947. He was a UPI reporter with an office in the same building. “They trashed the newsroom the last day, broken glass, whisky bottles all over,” he said. “They were really angry.” The eerie part, though, was the telephones. They were still ringing. “No newspaper,” O’Ryan said. “But lots of news.”


More in News & Comment

Washington State Capitol Building. Photo by Emma Epperly/WNPA Olympia News Bureau
Legislation targets rape kit backlog

WA has about 10,000 untested kits; new law would reduce testing time to 45 days

Two Issaquah High School students are under investigation after a racially insensitive photo surfaced over the weekend. Courtesy photo
Racially insensitive sign sparks investigation in Issaquah

High school students under investigation after Tolo photo goes viral.

Snohomish family detained by Border Patrol while on vacation

Little information has been provided since they were arrested Thursday near Tucson, Arizona.

Yaaah! Hipster Gregr of ‘Nerd Talk’ escapes city life

The morning host of radio station 107.7 The End has traded the Seattle vibe for Snohomish living.

Gov. Jay Inslee shakes hands with Dinah Griffey after signing Senate Bill 5649 on April 19. The law revises the statute of limitations for sex crimes. Photo by Emma Epperly, WNPA Olympia News Bureau
Hits and misses from Legislature’s 2019 session

New laws target vaccines, sex crimes and daylight savings; losers include sex ed and dwarf tossing bills.

If Inslee only knew, he might have run for president sooner

The governor isn’t a great dealmaker. His absences from Olympia may be helping get his bills passed.

Scott Barden stands next to the pit that will house the newest, and possibly final, section of the Cedar Hills Regional Landfill near Maple Valley. The pit is 120 feet deep, and around another 180 feet will be built on top of it over the next decade. Aaron Kunkler/staff photo
King County’s landfill is going to get bigger

A ninth cell will be built, extending its life by another decade.

An aircraft is pictured at King County International Airport, also known as Boeing Field. Photo courtesy of kingcounty.gov
King County wants to end deportation flights for ICE

Legal challenge expected from federal government.

USPS district manager Darrell Stoke, Janie Hendrix and Congressman Adam Smith (D-WA) unveil the plaque honorarily naming the Renton Highlands Post Office as the “James Marshall ‘Jimi’ Hendrix Post Office” on Friday, April 19. Photo by Haley Ausbun
Renton Highlands Post Office honors Jimi Hendrix

Postal Service connected Hendrix to family during his Army service.

Most Read