Bellevue Vote Proves the County-Wide Ban on Safe Drug Sites Is Unnecessary

Local jurisdictions can say “no” to the pilot program. Voters shouldn’t ban Seattle from saying “yes.”

The Bellevue City Council voted to ban safe drug sites on Monday. It was the wrong decision, but it was theirs to make—just as it is up to Seattleites whether to place such a site in Seattle and up to Redmond residents whether to put one in Redmond.

This is as it should be. Let the people most affected by a policy decide whether and how to institute it, even when they make the wrong decision. Some projects, like light rail expansion, require widespread coordination among many different regional governments for the common good, but when it comes to controversial pilot projects like safe drug sites, local governing bodies like cities should decide for themselves whether to opt in or opt out. Unfortunately, King County cities won’t be able to decide whether or not to host safe drug sites for much longer if Safe King County gets its way. The group says it has enough signatures to put onto the February 2018 ballot a measure that would ban safe drug sites throughout the county, full stop.

Also called supervised consumption sites or community health engagement locations (CHELs), the sites were part of a suite of recommendations made by an opioid epidemic task force on how to save lives and reduce harm in the face of spreading addiction and mounting casualties. Those comprehensive recommendations included increasing access to drug treatment programs and overdose-reversing medications, but the thorniest and most controversial recommendation was to establish two pilot CHELs in the county—places where people could consume illicit drugs in a clean, private space under medical supervision, with counselors and caseworkers on standby for anyone who wants them.

Critics of safe drug sites, including state Senator Mark Miloscia and Bothell City Councilmember Joshua Freed, assert that safe drug sites cause greater harm and death to drug users and society. As evidence, they point to the fact that opioid use has increased in Canada since the opening of the first supervised injection-only drug site, InSite, in 2003, and to the fact that the surrounding neighborhood of Downtown Eastside in Vancouver, B.C., is full of drug transactions and use.

This is backward, mixing up the treatment for an illness with the cause of the illness. Safe drug sites don’t cause drug use; drug use causes safe drug sites. That’s the whole point: You locate the sites in places where drug users are already concentrated—Downtown Eastside has been sketchy for generations. Miloscia’s and Freed’s argument is analogous to claiming that umbrellas cause rainfall.

Safe drug sites are clinics on the frontlines of our ongoing opioid epidemic. They are founded on the principle that we should help people without trying to force them to be sober, both because doing so doesn’t work and because consent matters in its own right.

By contrast, Safe King County wants to ban safe drug sites. It’s not enough that drug use is already illegal; opponents want zero tolerance. For them, the War on Drugs must know no boundaries.

This is wrong for two reasons. First, from a public health and safety standpoint, safe drug sites are objectively good, as measured by saved lives and taxpayer dollars. According to the American Medical Association, safe drug sites “reduce the number of overdose deaths, reduce transmission rates of infectious disease, and increase the number of individuals initiating treatment for substance use disorders, without increasing drug trafficking or crime in the area where the facilities are located.”

For those of us raised under the relentless propaganda campaign of the War on Drugs, this sounds counterintuitive to the point of absurdity. But the fact that a policy feels counterintuitive to people who are brainwashed to disbelieve it does not make it wrong. The War on Drugs has been waged for generations, yet drug use and abuse has only worsened. This suggests that violently ordering people not to use drugs may not be the most effective way to get them to stop using drugs.

Unlearning ideology is hard, but facts are facts. Here’s one: Of the thousands of people who have overdosed at InSite, not one has died from it. Ever. By contrast, 295 people died from accidental overdoses in 2015 in King County. All of them used unsafe drug sites, such as public parks and private apartments.

Safe drug sites work. But set aside their rightness or wrongness as a policy for a moment and consider who chooses. Should 51 percent of King County voters decide what happens to 100 percent of King County residents? Or should Seattleites decide for Seattle, and Bellevue for Bellevue?

editorial@seattleweekly.com

More in News & Comment

Redmond’s Neelam Chahlia crowned as Mrs. Washington America and competing for the national Mrs. America title on Aug. 26. Photo courtesy of Neelam Chahlia
Redmond’s Chahlia to compete for Mrs. America 2020 title

Mrs. Washington America winner says her journey embodies the ‘American Dream.’

Alaska Airlines to begin Everett-Spokane service on Nov. 4

It will be the carrier’s first in-state route and its 10th destination from Paine Field.

As his wife Heather looks on, John Norman gets a hug from his daughter Amber Nelson, and granddaughter Ashlee Nelson, right, after his replica of the Spirit of St. Louis flew for the first time from Arlington Municipal Airport on Sunday, July 28, 2019 in Arlington, Wash. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
This might be the best Spirit of St. Louis replica ever made

A plane like the one Charles Lindbergh flew across the Atlantic logged its first flight in Arlington.

Renton Police Officer Tanuj Soni has been charged with fourth-degree assault with sexual motivation and abuse of office. Photo courtesy of City of Renton
Court documents reveal details of alleged assault by a Renton police officer

Deputy Chief says RPD is performing an internal investigation

Chronicling the last years of a dying North Cascades glacier

For nearly four decades, scientist Mauri Pelto has journeyed to measure the melting Columbia Glacier.

What can otters tell us about watershed pollution?

An Oregon professor spent a year on Whidbey studying river otters for insight into the environment.

Lying, spying and destroying evidence spur guardian reforms

Judges say court-appointed guardians broke the law to keep a child away from her troubled parents.

Woman accused of trying to lure girl from family in Edmonds

The Lynnwood suspect allegedly was also seen photographing the 4-year-old at the Edmonds Yacht Club.

Bikini baristas could take dress code fight to Supreme Court

For now, they’ve requested a rehearing after the federal court sided with the city of Everett in July.

Most Read