Why the Jungle Sweeps are Bound to Fail

The city’s plan for clearing homeless encampments ignores the fundamental reasons people are there to begin with.

On Monday, the Union Gospel Mission began outreach to the Jungle, a stretch of unpermitted homeless encampments along I-5. The religious agency is working with Mayor Ed Murray’s office, which plans to clear out the Jungle within weeks. “We hope to transition those currently living in tents under the freeway into stable shelter, while supporting public safety in the area,” Murray said in a press release.

The Jungle is a decades-old no man’s land of tents and improvised structures hidden beneath the highway and behind the bushes and trees of the East Duwamish Greenbelt. As a recent city assessment noted, the area contains human poop, campfires, used needles, and a great deal of trash. It is also refuge to hundreds of Seattleites, five of whom were shot in January in an apparent dispute over drug money. At the scene of that shooting, Murray told reporters that Seattle must “finally take control” of the Jungle. “We have to go into these encampments…[to] offer people services, clean the place up, and try and get people out,” he said.

This isn’t the first time an executive in shining armor has tried to raze the Jungle. As Casey Jaywork previously reported, Seattle already cleared the Jungle in 1994, 1998, and 2003. As in those previous years, homeless advocates are raising hell: a dozen protesters confronted leaders at city hall on Monday, demanding the Jungle remain available to campers. Other critics point out that while Union Gospel Mission technically has enough space to absorb the Jungle population temporarily, there is no sustainable plan for where or how to house hundreds of high-needs homeless folks in the long term. Seattle’s shelter network is filled to the brink, and there’s a multi-year waitlist for public housing.

But really, the question of shelter capacity is academic. If history is any guide, most Jungle residents will decline offers of shelter and instead migrate into even more reclusive encampments or onto the streets of surrounding neighborhoods. Eventually many will return to the Jungle, as they have in the past. Is their decision to return reckless and “service resistant”? No, councilmember Mike O’Brien told Jaywork earlier this week. “A mat on a gym floor with 50 other people where you have no privacy and there are other people that are suffering from mental health [problems] that are going to be screaming in the middle of the night, and your belongings may be stolen—that is not an upgrade for [campers],” he says. “If they say, ‘No thanks, I’m better off where I am, I’m better off in the woods, and if you don’t let me be in these woods I’ll go find some other woods in town to hide in’—that’s a rational decision that they’re making.”

Sweeps feel good, and make for great TV. They’re a fast, cathartic response to an ugly, urgent problem. But they also, almost by definition, ignore the underlying reasons people have chosen to live in our urban woods. As such, they are bound to fail.

There are other options out there. Real Change founder Tim Harris proposes city leaders use the Jungle as a way to bring services to an already-concentrated homeless population. This is just one example of a Jungle strategy that doesn’t evict hundreds of Seattleites from what meager homes they’ve scraped together and then assume the resulting refugees will evaporate into thin air. This criticism isn’t so much ethical as pragmatic: if we aren’t honest in our conversations about why people are in the Jungle to begin with, then we are doomed to repeat a history of spending lots of money and having little to show for it in a few years.

The mayor is right that Seattle cannot afford to ignore the Jungle’s public health and safety hazards. Yet mass eviction is not a solution. It will merely push campers elsewhere, for a while. Despite the humane gloss of UGM’s outreach provides, the mayor’s proposed sweep is just another round of whack-a-mole with the homeless.

More in News & Comment

Bob Ferguson is going after controversial Trump administration policies once again. Photo by Joe Mabel/Wikimedia Commons
AG Ferguson Takes on Trump’s Immigrant Family Separation

Washington’s Attorney General plans to sue the federal government over the “zero tolerance” policy.

Since he first ran for the King County Prosecutor’s Office in 2007, Dan Satterberg has never faced an electoral challenger. Photo courtesy Dan Satterberg
The Political Invulnerability of King County Prosecutor Dan Satterberg

He hasn’t faced an electoral challenge since taking office. Does his new longshot social justice-minded challenger stand a chance?

Aneelah Afzali, executive director of American Muslim Empowerment Network, was the featured speaker at 21 Progress’s Rise #7 event. Photo by Melissa Hellmann
How a Local Muslim Activist Is Bridging the Faith Divide to Foster Hope

As part of 21 Progress’ Rise series, Aneelah Afzali drew parallels between anti-Muslim rhetoric and immigration xenophobia.

After Seattle’s controversial employee head tax was repealed, King County Executive Dow Constantine wants to bond against existing tax revenues to generate $100 million for affordable housing. Photo by Joe Mabel/Wikipedia Commons
County Executive Proposes $100 Million Affordable Housing Bond

The money was already coming, but Constantine wants to speed up the process.

The exterior of the University District crisis pregnancy center, 3W Medical for Women. Photo by Keiko DeLuca
How Title X Cuts Impact UW Women’s Health

Some student advocates worry that slashed budgets could drive student to misleading crisis pregnancy centers.

Trans Pride Seattle seeks to strengthen the transgender and non-binary community. 
Photo courtesy of Gender Justice League
Trans Pride Seattle Continues Marching

In light of federal budget cuts, the parade that highlights marginalized voices survives due to community crowdfunding.

As the executive director of the Tenants Union of Washington State, Violet Lavatai (left) believes that YIMBY policies 
do not actually help the communities most in need of housing. Photo courtesy Tenants Union of Washington State
The Growing Power of Seattle YIMBYs

The tech-funded “Yes in My Backyard” movement thinks the housing crisis can be solved by rapid development, but does it only benefit those at the top?

Hidden River Farms is 100 acres of farmland in Grays Harbor County. Photo by Lucia Wyss
Sowing the Seeds of Mental Health

Suicide is an epidemic amongst agricultural workers, but young farmers and state legislators are working to find solutions.

Most Read