Seattle mayoral candidate Cary Moon says Murray should resign. Photo courtesy of the Moon campaign

Did Murray Go Far Enough? Two Opponents Argue the Mayor Should Resign Altogether

Cary Moon and Mike McGinn say the sex abuse lawsuit compromises Murray’s ability to lead. Nonsense, says Murray camp.

With the announcement that he would be dropping his bid for re-election behind him, Seattle Mayor Ed Murray is now facing calls from two of the race’s remaining candidates to go farther and relinquish his office immediately.

Previously, Gender Justice League director Danni Askini had called for his resignation on the grounds that allegations that the mayor sexually abused teen boys decades ago, and the scandal around it, will distract from city business and pain survivors as long as he remains in office. The call, now echoed by mayoral candidates Mike McGinn and Cary Moon, focuses on Murray’s response to the allegations—in particular, the fact that Murray pointed to his accusers’ criminal histories as reason to doubt them—which they say has made him unfit to lead a city that is home to many survivors of sexual violence.

In a statement Tuesday morning reacting to the news that Murray has dropped out of the race, Moon thanked the mayor for his service, then said, “I believe it’s in the best interests of everyone—especially the many survivors of sexual assault re-experiencing their own traumas—for the Mayor to step down now so that City Hall can get back to work. An aggressive legal fight, where Mayor Murray feels compelled to use all the power of his position as a public official to demean and even silence his accusers, is deeply divisive to our community and triggering for survivors of sexual assault. Whatever the outcome of the judicial process, it’s not appropriate for a public official to do this while serving as the leader of our city.”

But would this really help the city? If the mayor resigns, it will create a leadership vacuum. Council President Bruce Harrell would become mayor and take control of Murray’s administration, and the council would select a replacement to finish Harrell’s term. In that case, both the mayor’s throne and a city council seat would be filled by newcomers occupying someone else’s office and staff. As we wrote in this week’s editorial, “It’s hard to imagine how Council President Bruce Harrell, who would take his place, would be more effective (that’s not a dig on Harrell, but on the reality of any Councilmember getting shuttled to the seventh floor of City Hall for seven months of work).”

Asked by Seattle Weekly whether Murray’s resignation would disrupt city business more than him finishing his term, Moon said, “I think the mayor fortunately has surrounded himself…by really great people, and I think we can count on the staff of the city to step up…and keep their eye on the ball without him.”

McGinn was more concise, thanks to the discipline of Twitter:

He also suggested Murray donate his remaining campaign funds to a charity that supports survivors of sexual abuse.

Jeff Reading, spokesperson for Murray, responded Tuesday to both candidates: “Mayor Murray will remain mayor until the end of his term, as he said today. Mayor Murray selflessly removed himself from the mayor’s race to allow the campaign to focus on the issues that matter most to the future of this city. Mike McGinn and Cary Moon should use this moment to promote their visions for the city around affordability, equity, growth, transportation, livability and homelessness. Instead, McGinn and Moon are trying — nakedly, opportunistically, and belatedly— to extract political advantage from the allegations against the mayor. McGinn and Moon would do better to focus on how their shared, failed ‘lesser Seattle’ visions will not cancel each other out in the primary rather than cling to desperate attacks against someone who is no longer a candidate in the race.”

McGinn says that another reason for Murray to step down is that there’s a potential conflict of interest between a his mayoral duties and a proposed legal defense fund to help him pay for his court defense. Murray’s supporters have sent a letter to the Seattle Ethics and Election Commission (SEEC) asking for an advisory opinion on whether such a fund would be ethically acceptable. The Seattle Times published the letter here.

“Ed is seeking permission to have a legal defense fund, in which donors can give unlimited amounts,” said McGinn. “I know they claim it would be anonymous, but it defies common sense to think that someone making large contributions couldn’t find a way to make sure that the mayor knew about it. That’s an inappropriate conflict” of interest, he said, “for Ed Murray’s surrogates to be raising unlimited, anonymous donations while Ed Murray is still making important decisions that might affect those donors.”

The SEEC will meet on Tuesday to discuss whether the proposed legal fund for Murray violates ethical rules.

More in News & Comment

What Becomes of Animal Rights Activists After the Action Is Over?

Peter Young and Justin Samuel helped launch a new era in the fight against fur. Then they went their separate ways.

Sound Publishing archives
State Gets an Earful on Legalizing Home-Grown Marijuana

Unique among the states that have legalized cannabis, Washington bans homegrows.

Judge Veronica Alicea-Galván’s courtroom just after hearing arguments on the I-27 lawsuit on Friday, Oct. 13, 2017. From left to right: Mark Cooke of the ACLU-WA; State Rep. Drew Stokesbary, serving as counsel to the defendants; Bothell City Council member and I-27 organizer Joshua Freed; Jeff Slayton, counsel from the Seattle City Attorney’s Office; court staff; and the brown-coated shoulder of Dr. Bob Wood, former director of the HIV/AIDS Program at Public Health Seattle/King County. Photo by Casey Jaywork
Judge Blocks I-27, Saves Supervised Consumption Sites

The ballot initiative would have prohibited supervised consumption sites (CHELs) throughout King County.

King County Executive Dow Constantine tells President Trump that he is “failing the American people” at the protest of U.S. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos’ trip to Bellevue on Friday. Nicole Jennings/staff photo
Betsy DeVos’ Bellevue Visit Draws Hundreds of Protestors

“You are failing the American people.”

Photo by Casey Jaywork
DOJ: Seattle Police Are Complying With Consent Decree

But Judge Robart could side with monitor Merrick Bobb, who has said SPD is not in full compliance.

Steve Fournier (with microphone) and Loverboy lead singer Mike Reno (in glasses) on stage at Xfinity Arena last Friday. (Diane Webb /
Everybody’s Working For a Refund: Loverboy’s Concert in Everett Was a Flop, and Fans Want Their Money Back

Last month in Everett, the ailing lead singer left the stage and an audience member stepped in.

Trump Move Will Send Insurance Premiums Soaring in Washington

The state was prepared for Trump pulling the rug out from under Obamacare. But it’s not pretty.

Photo via Washington Convention Center
Sister’s Work Could Raise Conflict Issues for Jenny Durkan If Elected

T. Ryan Durkan has worked on projects ranging from the Convention Center to Sound Transit.

Councilmembers Mike O’Brien and Kirsten Harris-Talley speak to reporters in the Sam Smith room at City Hall on the morning of Thursday, Oct. 12. Photo by Casey Jaywork
Proposal: Tax Big Business to Raise Over $20 Million Annually for Housing and Shelter

Seattle City Councilmembers Harris-Talley and O’Brien want a #HousingForAllSeattle budget.

Most Read