Sonics Fans Are Skeptical of the City’s KeyArena Plans, and That Could Be a Good Thing

The pressure is on for the city to ink a KeyArena deal that’s good for taxpayers. That’s usually not the case with sports arenas.

Seattle politics are weird. That’s hardly a point that bears repeating, but what’s happening now with KeyArena is a prime example of how differently things work in our city.

Typically, here’s how a pro sports arena comes into being. First, a few really rich guys raise the prospect of bringing a football or basketball or baseball team to town—or, if those teams already exist in the city, a few really rich guys threaten to move the team away. Unlike, say, affordable housing or public schools, pro sports teams usually enjoy wide public support, meaning that either of these prospects—a new team coming or an old team leaving—becomes a primary concern for a significant number of voters. With the bait set, the really rich guys pull the string on the trap, demanding a lot of freebies in exchange for the team—often in the form of a publicly funded stadium—that essentially allows them to realize all the profit while taxpayers foot the bill. Awful as the deal may be, local politicians are loath to upset their sports-loving constituency, and in the name of civic pride, they bankroll whatever it is the really rich guys say they need. A few fuddy-duddies may point out that this is an injustice to the poor or whomever, but for the most part, everyone’s happy that they have a local team to root for.

Now consider KeyArena, where a group of well-heeled investors want to oversee a massive renovation of the city-owned property for the possible return of the Sonics, and where almost every aspect of the above narrative is turned on its head. Sure, there are lots of rich guys involved in the proposed $564 million renovation, but that’s where the similarities end. Where these arena deals usually come with a promise of a pro team, backers of the Key renovation are actively discouraging the notion that an NBA team could come to Seattle in the near term (though they emphasize that a hockey team could be closer at hand). Although the deals usually assume some public buy-in, this renovation would be privately funded. Strangest of all, where it’s usually sports fans that are driving the push for arena deals, in the Key’s case, the plan appears to be roundly despised by Seattle’s basketball fans, who pine for the return of the SuperSonics but consider KeyArena to be partly responsible for the city losing the team to Oklahoma City in the first place. It’s impossible to ignore the outright vitriol that the plan to renovate KeyArena draws in online forums. “Isnt that the same shitty building as to why the Sonics are in OKC!?!” reads a typical, typo-filled Facebook reaction to the renovation plan.

In short, where most sports arenas are bad deals that everyone wants, the KeyArena renovation may be a decent deal that nobody wants. Odd as this situation is, though, there’s reason to believe it could produce a far better plan than most cities can expect when it comes to sports arenas. Two concerns over the Key plan are, first, traffic in Uptown and, to a lesser extent, the role of some public money flowing into the arena in the future via reinvestment of taxes collected from the arena. Knowing that the public is skeptical of a Key renovation, the city should feel emboldened to press their hand on both these fronts when negotiating with Oak View Group, the private firm the city last week designated its “preferred partner” for KeyArena redevelopment. Mayor Ed Murray said last week that he wants to see a better transportation plan put forth by Oak View than has already been offered. We agree, and that improvement should include more investment in public transportation to the arena beyond the expansion of Monorail services that has already been proposed by Oak View. The Oak View plan also assumes $40 million in “city tax reinvestment” into the arena, which means a portion of admission taxes collected at the arena after its renovation would be earmarked for reinvestment into the Key to the benefit of its private managers. Oak View would argue that it’s a fair deal, since the tax revenue wouldn’t even exist if it weren’t for them; while that’s true, it’s still a fact that the proposal represents an earmark of $40 million in public dollars for the arena. The city should not grant such financing lightly.

Of course, the reason many fans are skeptical of this plan to begin with is that they prefer another plan on the table—Chris Hansen’s proposed SoDo arena, which would also be built with private dollars. The City Council effectively put that plan on ice when it refused to vacate a portion of Occidental Avenue on which the arena would be built. The fact that the council shunned one good deal only increases the imperative that with KeyArena, the city comes up with a great deal.

There’s been concern expressed that while the city as a whole is skeptical of the Key renovation, Murray is eager to ink a deal by the end of his term to burnish his legacy, meaning he won’t walk away from the table even if the figures don’t add up. We hope that’s not the case, but if it is, it would be a misread on the mayor’s part. With people already skeptical, they’ll be quick to smell a boondoggle where, in other cities, basketball-hungry fans may smell nothing but hardwood. Seattle’s weird that way. Murray should take advantage of it.

More in News & Comment

All Home board members meet in Seattle on April 23 to talk about its structure. Photo by Josh Kelety
The Never-Ending Search for an Effective King County Homeless Plan

While All Home attempts to address the issue, the group’s lack of actual power results in little change.

March for Our Lives Seattle founders Emilia Allard (right) and Rhiannon Rasaretnam (left) spoke at the rally on March 24, 2018. Photo by Melissa Hellmann
Gun Control May Be Headed to the Ballot Box Again

A ballot initiative could restrict semi-automatic weapon sales, including raising the purchase age to 21.

Rodney Tom. Photo by John Stang
Rodney Tom’s Centrist Dance

After party-hopping from Republican to Democrat and back again (and again), can the fiscal conservative woo voters in the 48th?

Throwing Shade: How a Lack of Trees Hurts Seattle Minorities

Studies show minimal tree canopy cover negatively impacts the city’s vulnerable neighborhoods.

Photo by SounderBruce/Flickr
The Emerald City’s Smoggy Gray

Forest fires, wood smoke, and traffic are making it hard to breathe Seattle’s air.

UW’s Storefront Studio Project Revitalizes Historic Northwest Streets

For 15 years, the student-driven program has given new life to thoroughfares in Northwest communities.

A Canadian safe consumption site in Lethbridge. Photo supplied by ARCHES in Lethbridge
County Plans for Second Safe Drug Site Now on Hold

Following intense resistance to the proposal from the suburbs, county officials are taking a wait-and-see approach.

David Swaintek stands in front of his junk removal truck. Photo courtesy of Hanna Swaintek/JDog Junk Removal Lake Union
Veteran’s Junk Removal Franchise Strives for Environmental Sustainability

In light of China’s recent recycling regulations, JDog Junk Removal could help reduce the burden on landfills.

Most Read