News or Exploitation? Students Protest Video Showing SPU Student Disarming School Shooter

Several media outlets fought for more than a year to obtain the video, over the protest of victim families.

Following a lengthy legal battle, a number of media outlets, including The Seattle Times, KIRO 7 and KING 5, have obtained and posted surveillance video from the June 2014 shooting at Seattle Pacific University over the protests of victims and the school.

The video is dramatic, showing SPU student Jon Meis rush shooter Aaron Ybarra, pepper spray him, and take away his shotgun. After taking Ybarra’s gun, Meis rushes him again as Ybarra takes out a hunting knife. The Seattle Times notes that it chose to only show the part of the video showing Meis’ heroism, and “not releasing any images that show the shooting or victims.” KIRO 7 did not post any raw video, but only a “portion of the video in the context of our news broadcasts.”

Meis’ heroic actions that day have long been known; among other things, there was a push on Reddit to buyout Meis’ wedding registry. Yet the surveillance video, seized by police for investigation, had not been made public while SPU and lawyers for the shooting victims fought its release—suggesting the video had no value beyond to boosting ratings and pageviews.

One person was killed and two others wounded in the June 4 shooting, which had resurfaced in the news even before the video’s release on account of the shooting in Orlando.

The school and victims were initially successful in their suit, but an appellant court overruled a lower court’s decision.

Now, with the video released, the debate has been reignited: Is showing video from a murder scene a public service, or just exploitative?

Several SPU students took to Twitter to call out media outlets for showing the video.

SPU also released a statement last night, reading in part: “We are disappointed by the release of the surveillance videos of the June 5, 2014, shooting on our campus. We, along with others, have pursued legal action to stop the videos’ release in order to protect individual privacy and prevent the emotional distress these images will have on our community.”

In an email, Times spokeswoman China Davis sent us this statement, attributed to managing editor Jim Simon:

“We appreciate the valid concerns of people opposed to the release and airing of the surveillance videos, particularly those in the SPU community. We tried to balance those sensitivities with what we felt was the legitimate news value of a small segment of the video.

“After a lengthy newsroom discussion, The Times made the decision to run only the 47-second short segment of the video showing the courageous actions by student safety monitor Jon Meis to confront and tackle the shooter. Ultimately, we decided the video clip was newsworthy because it offered the public a much more powerful understanding of the extraordinary efforts Meis made to save lives than any of the previously written descriptions of those events had. Editing of the video was done carefully so that no images of the shootings or victims were shown. We also removed advertising that normally runs with our videos.”

Tracy Norlen, director of public information at SPU, said the media outlets not airing the entire video did not change the university’s outlook on the issue. Asked how showing Meis’ actions could be traumatizing to victims, she referred back to the university’s statement.

More in News & Comment

Maru Mora Villalpando stands outside of the Seattle Immigration Court after her first deportation hearing on March 15, 2018. Photo by Melissa Hellmann
Anti-ICE Organizer Stands Defiant at Her Own Deportation Hearing

Hundreds gathered in support of Maru Mora-Villalpando outside of Seattle Immigration Court.

Suburban and Rural Students Join the Call for Gun Control

What the National School Walkout looked like outside of Seattle.

Garfield High School students stand in silence to protest gun violence. Photo by Melissa Hellmann
Seattle Students Take Part in the National School Walkout

Garfield High School students pay tribute to the Parkland victims by rallying for gun control.

Issaquah will not be housing a supervised consumption site like the facilities found in Vancouver, B.C. Photo by Nicole Jennings
Reproductive rights marchers during the 2017 Seattle Pride Parade. Photo by Bobby Arispe Jr./Flickr
Seattle Abortion Providers Weigh in on Reproductive Parity Act

The newly passed state legislation will cover abortion services for private insurance holders.

A pro-immigrant sign at the 
                                2018 Women’s March in Seattle. 
Photo by David Lee/Flickr
Can Immigration Issues Be Fixed at the County Level?

King County establishes new commission to support immigrant and refugee communities.

Photo by Taylor McAvoy
No Longer Silent: Sexual Assault Survivors Push Legislative Change

Seeking systematic reforms, victims spoke up this legislative session.

Photo by Nicolas Vigier/Flickr
Legislators Come to Agreement on Deadly Force Reform

An agreement between lawmakers, activists, and police alters and passes the I-940 ballot initiative.

Namasgay participants gather at a local meetup. Photo courtesy of Frank Macri
Making a Home for Spiritually-Minded LGBTQ Folks

Namasgay hosts local events for queer people seeking greater self-actualization.

Most Read