A Most Wanted Man: Philip Seymour Hoffman Versus al-Qaida (and the CIA)

When Philip Seymour Hoffman died in February, he had several films half-completed or in the can. Their quality, as it is for any actor, even the Oscar-winning elite, is always going to be variable. A star performer can only dictate so much of the show, though this adaptation of a lesser 2008 John le Carré novel will, I think, be remembered as the best among Hoffman’s posthumous releases. Directed by the very deliberate Dutch photographer-turned-filmmaker Anton Corbijn (Control, The American), A Most Wanted Man is a fatigued and belated picture—and I mean that as praise. It’s post-spy movie, post-Cold War, post-9/11. Hoffman plays a rumpled Hamburg cop, Bachmann, with failures in his past, who’s charged with the dirty work of counter-terrorism. There are no press conferences or posh U.N. cocktail parties for this schlub, who’s like a German variant on Lieutenant Frank Columbo: disrespected by his bosses, underestimated by his quarry, beloved by his team, but a wry, sad, solitary figure who expects the worst outcome from any investigation. Bachmann is a pessimist and alcoholic who listens to Beethoven late at night on his stereo, alone.

Crawling out of the Elbe, like a rat, is a Russian-Chechen Muslim we’ll come to know as Karpov (Grigory Dobrygin), though he has other names. Bachmann and his squad (including Continental all-stars Daniel Brühl and Nina Hoss) follow Karpov intently without arresting him, hoping he’ll lead to bigger fish. His bosses are dubious; a separate, rival German intelligence agency interferes; and he’s even got to negotiate with the CIA—represented in butch slacks and blonde buzz-cut by Robin Wright—to allow Karpov room to roam. (Here Rachel McAdams shows up as a naïve, sympathetic human-rights lawyer—riding a bike, of course.) Will Karpov plant a bomb in the rush-hour subway or lead Bachmann to an important al-Qaida funding link? Related within a few days’ time and surveillance, that’s the essential plot.

Gadgets don’t agree with the genius of le Carré. If intelligence can simply be gathered by satellite, computer, and wi-fi, what’s the point of the face-to-face deceptions and codes of spycraft? The recent Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy was a much better movie as it evoked the old, analog Cold War; unreliable technology meant that human relationships, and betrayals, were paramount. Hoffman would’ve been a better fit in that bygone world of smoky negotiation and curdled compromise. In The New York Times last week, le Carré said as much, calling him “the only American actor I knew who could play my character George Smiley.”

Carve those words in granite. I’ll most remember Hoffman from this movie in a brief scene, set on a ferry, where Bachmann tries to keep a nervous young Muslim informant in the fold. The kid is scared, understandably, and Bachmann agrees with his every complaint. But then Hoffman, the actor, leans in like a lead shield. He absorbs all the tsuris of the younger performer (Mehdi Dehbi) like a sin-eater, hugs him, and keeps the invaluable source intact. It’s all in a day’s work for Bachmann, but for Hoffman, too, there must’ve been costs. Opens Fri., July 25 at Seven Gables, Oak Tree, and Pacific Place. Rated R. 121 minutes.


comments powered by Disqus