In ‘Certain Women,’ the Story’s Not the Point

This series of vignettes, set around wintry Livingston, Montana, is more about the tone than the tale.

Courtesy FilmScience

Kelly Reichardt’s films quietly creep up on plotlines, sniffing around the possibilities of storytelling before shifting away into a different kind of thing. In Meek’s Cutoff, a wagon train of pioneers is lost in the parched West; in Night Moves, a group of environmental saboteurs plans a bombing; in Wendy and Lucy, a traveler faces a transportation problem on the road to somewhere. None of these situations is allowed to come together in the usual kind of completion, which means you’re left with Reichardt’s wonderful way with actors and dialogue and a sense that we should be concentrating on gesture and intonation rather than plot.

I don’t want all movies to be like this, but I’m grateful for Reichardt’s talent for warping our movie expectations. With that in mind, I was intrigued by the opening of her new film, Certain Women, which uncannily echoes the first scene of Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho: A woman, no longer young, is wrapping up an afternoon tryst with a married man during a lunch break at a hotel in the West. There will be no murders ahead, except maybe of the spiritual kind—Hitchcock was interested in that, too. This vignette is the first of three (based on stories by Montana-born Maile Meloy) that will unfold and slightly overlap. All take place in or around wintry Livingston, Montana.

The woman is Laura (Laura Dern), a lawyer whose client (Jared Harris) is suffering from a work-related head injury. He doesn’t listen to her, probably because she’s a woman, but she doesn’t do a great job of listening to him, either. The second episode begins with married couple Gina (Michelle Williams) and Ryan (James LeGros) camping in their fashionable yurt with their bored adolescent daughter. These people aren’t good at listening to each other, either (Ryan, in fact, is the married guy Laura is having the affair with). Gina and Ryan are trying to get an aging man (Rene Auberjonois) to sell a pile of sandstone bricks in his yard. Gina is very concerned that the house they build on their property should be native and authentic and—you know, all that. But there’s a sense that taking these rocks away from the man’s house will really be taking something away.

The third strand is arranged around the repetitive chores of a lonely ranch hand (Lily Gladstone). One night she sits in during a night class on school law, for teachers. The instructor is a newly minted lawyer (Kristen Stewart) who must drive four hours from Livingston just to teach this class. The scenes between these two at a truck stop show what Reichardt does very well, employing turns of phrase that don’t waste a syllable on unnecessary exposition and catching mysteriously heartbreaking details like the way Stewart wipes the corner of her mouth with a napkin that has not yet been unwrapped from around its cutlery. The two actresses are exactly in the movie’s quiet mode, yet they are very distinct from each other: Gladstone is moony and plain-acting, Stewart sharp and anxious. The audience sees, before the characters do, that the ranch hand is hopelessly lovestruck.

Because of the location and the compact look into the lives of half-realized people, Certain Women will inevitably invite comparisons with the writing of Raymond Carver and Richard Ford, which is fair. That these situations are here filtered through a female sensibility is crucial, but Reichardt is even-handed about her sympathies—she’s aware that both sexes screw things up at a tragically high rate. The more important difference with someone like Carver is that Reichardt is truly cinematic, not literary. In one long-held shot, a character withdraws her hopes from Livingston as she drives a pick-up truck out of the place; we watch her face just to the right of the frame as we notice the town passing by and eventually retreating through the back window. This is what it means to leave Livingston, Montana, as a little dream dies and life resumes, and it’s the language of film that conveys that emotional punch. I think it would be interesting if Reichardt did something in a louder key—maybe knock off a thriller or something. But what she does, she does extremely well. Certain Women, Rated R. Opens Fri., Oct. 21 at the Egyptian Theater.

More in Film

Tomasz Kot and Joanna Kulig simmer as musicians in love in <em>Cold</em> <em>War</em>. Photo by Lukasz Bak
The Warm Musical Romance of ‘Cold War’

The gorgeous Polish tale of love behind the Iron Curtain would be a layup for the Best Foreign Language Film Oscar in a non-‘Roma’ year.

KiKi Layne (Tish) and Stephan James (Fonny) star in ‘If Beale Street Could Talk.’ Photo by Tatum Mangus/Annapurna Pictures
Meandering Along ‘Beale Street’

Barry Jenkins follows up ‘Moonlight’ with the textured racial mood piece, ‘If Beale Street Could Talk.’

Jason Momoa and Patrick Wilson square off in ‘Aquaman.’ Photo courtesy Warner Bros. Pictures
‘Aquaman’ Can’t Figure Out Which Wave to Surf

The latest DC Comic movie struggles to find a balance between keeping a straight face and having fun.

Emily Blunt takes on the role of the magical nanny in Mary Poppins Returns. 
Photo courtesy Walt Disney Studios
‘Mary Poppins Returns’ Boasts Nostalgic Musical Charm

The first soundtrack album I ever knew deeply was Mary Poppins, and… Continue reading

Spider-Folks from various dimensions come together in ‘Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse.’ Image courtesy Columbia Pictures/Sony
‘Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse’ Gets Caught in Its Own Web

The animated comic book gets stuck up on its multiverse fan service.

Rachel Weisz and Emma Stone battle for the queen’s attention in <em>The Favourite</em>. Photo by Atsushi Nishijima/Twentieth Century Fox
Black Comedy with a Regal Veneer

Emma Stone and Rachel Weisz bring catty rivalry to the queen’s court in ‘The Favourite.’

Yalitza Aparicio (left) makes her feature debut as Cleo, the central character in <em>Roma</em>. Photo by Carlos Somonte
‘Roma’ Makes an Epic Film Out of an Intimate Story

Alfonso Cuarón’s memories and vision guide the Spanish-language Oscar front-runner about a young housekeeper in 1970s Mexico.

Taron Egerton (Robin) and Jamie Foxx (John) take another crack at the classic in Robin Hood. Photo by Larry Horricks
The Arrows Miss Their Mark in ‘Robin Hood’

The legend’s latest rendition can’t overcome its modern smirky tone and bland lead actor.

Mahershala Ali and Viggo Mortensen form the odd couple that carries Green Book. 
Courtesy Universal Pictures
Stellar Acting Makes ‘Green Book’ A Smooth Ride

Despite its cornball touches, Mahershala Ali and Viggo Mortensen shine as a 1960s jazz pianist and his hired muscle.

Image by Drew Struzan/Disney
Holiday Movie Streaming Picks

Get in the festive spirit at home with these beloved seasonal films.

Viola Davis and Cynthia Erivo star in ‘Widows.’ Photo by Merrick Morton
Crime Doesn’t Pay Off in ‘Widows’

Steve McQueen’s feminist heist thriller stretches itself far too thin.

Tim Blake Nelson plays the titular Buster Scruggs. Photo courtesy Netflix
‘The Ballad of Buster Scruggs’ Is a Wagon Train of Dark Mischief

The Coen brothers’ new anthology seves as a glorious ode to Westerns’ dusty death.