Top

music

Stories

 

In Defense of Courtney

It's not her, Seattle, it's you.

It's often been posited that the people who make the best music aren't necessarily the most likable. I figured that one out at 14, when I realized that although Appetite for Destruction was the ultimate record in my high-haired universe, Axl Rose was the kind of guy who could break more than a girl's heart. That he'd go home and write "Sweet Child o' Mine" for her didn't make it any better.

If you're an original Seattleite or been here long enough, you've heard or have your own juicy Courtney Love story. The Green River Killer has a better Northwest reputation. And maybe she has been: a jerk, a bad parent (a trait male rockers are rarely called to task for), an addict, completely Fruit Loops, and the maker of a record so bad it may be the most successful at sucking ever. But she's also made two good albums—including her latest, Nobody's Daughter—one great one, and another as next to perfect as it can be.

For me, Hole's Live Through This was a life-changer. The rallying cry that inspired me to get out of my 800-person town in North Dakota. And for all you shouting that "She didn't write that record!", I say prove it and/or fuck it. I don't really care. I, and a lot of other girls, needed to hear those words come out of that mouth at that time in our lives. And I'm grateful enough to forgive her crimes, the worst of which is being a self-saboteur, and learn from them. Lesson one: While reveling in addiction, do not, under any circumstances, let someone near your face with a scalpel.

Seattle will never be a Courtney town for the same reason it will always struggle to have a successful sports franchise: It shuns the embrace of excess. Seattle teams strive to be just good enough to keep up attendance, but they never shell out the "Yankee Cash" or tolerate the superstar-type players it takes to win. And if Courtney Love is anything, she is too much. Too loud, too blonde, too opinionated, too damaged, too wasted, and the ultimate Seatown taboo: too ambitious.

Everyone knows that if Emerald City success should come your way, don't act like you want or like it, lest a scarlet "S" for "sellout" be tattooed on your forehead. It's a sentiment that transcends music, forcing tech millionaires to sport Old Navy polo shirts and rich girls to shop Pacific Place in pajamas. In cities like New York or L.A., where too much applies only to the number on the scale, opinions of Love are more favorable.

So go see her headline the 'Shoot hoping for disaster, ready to snicker safely in the crowd and talk smack you'd never say to her face. Why? Because women as smart and crazy as Courtney have been scaring the pants off people since the beginning of time. But be warned, if caught, you'll likely get punched in your shit-talking face.

music@seattleweekly.com

 
  • David Eagle 11/24/2010 9:16:00 AM

    Ohhhh Duma Duma Duma... ...I guess if I've been forgiving Gene Simmons for his crimes, you are entitled to turn the other cheek for Courtney Love-Cox. I'm so impressed with your writing, old friend. What a delight to find. I've got some stuff for you to hear. catch me

  • alaskan lonny 11/10/2010 1:00:00 PM

    I thought she was quite good and almost seemed... dare i say, healthy? It was a highlight of my trip to Seattle for Bumbershoot. That and Weezer, and The Decemberists... and almost meeting John Roderick of the Long Winters... and The Raveonette's...

  • Lola 09/29/2010 4:21:00 PM

    "I thought that this nearly 50-year old woman" She's in her mid-40s

  • A 09/18/2010 6:15:00 AM

    Just found this site (I live in Arkansas)...oddly I'm writing my own piece called "In Defense of Courtney Love." From ages 17-22 I listened to Hole, not Nirvana. I was a metalhead so starved for good female musicianship that I listened to Lita Ford and Doro Pesch in between Slayer and Testament albums. Seattle took over the world and I discovered Pretty on the Inside and the most talented female rock singer and lyricist in existence. I am 36 now, a writer, with a much-diminished outward punk/metal aesthetic, but I have never given up on Courtney Love. Leave her alone. We all have problems and demons. I don't love every one of her songs, and her antics are kooky as hell sometimes, but when she's on, the woman is a goddess. She's brilliant. Best female rock voice. Ever.

  • Anna 09/16/2010 9:53:00 AM

    hey why don't you kiss Courtney's @ss?? Her own daugter turned her back on her. Doesn't it mean something?? If I were so close to her as you Americans I couldn't refrain from throwing a rotten tomato at her face. Though she actually deserves something really harder...

  • Stacia 09/09/2010 2:10:00 PM

    Courtney Love has once again proven herself as a completely succumbed fool to the Hollywood glamour that prompted her to undergo gastric bypass surgery in lieu of living a healthy lifestyle. She has been quoted as stating that “The worst thing that could happen to a girl is getting fat”, so I wanted to confront her the only way I knew how, just to verify that this inane statement was truly what she wanted to convey. I made a brightly colored sign that I knew would get her attention after I fought my way down front and center at Bumbershoot. This method had worked for me in the past with her, about fifteen years ago! So, she did stop to address me in the middle of her arena show and said “Actually, yea, being fat – it kinda is [the worst]. Especially to the boys!” She gestured with an accusing finger to the massive sausage fest that was overrunning the front and center spots. I don’t know what I was expecting her to say, but maybe some kind of disclosure that there are a heck of a lot worse life events that can happen to a female that don’t involve beleaguring over her muffin-top or cellulite. I thought that this nearly 50-year old woman, who has been in the music business for more than half her life, might have encountered some enlightenment along the way, and maybe even some real self-worth. Bumbershoot 2010 at Seattle Center was headlining Weezer and the front railing was lined with boys who were only staying up front in the hopes of catching a beaver shot of Mz Love. Of course, they were not disappointed. Later, I held up the opposite side of my sign with the same message that I gave her 15 years ago circa "Live Through This", the message isn't as important as what she had to say to me this time - "Is that the same girl with the fat sign? Let me see you, are you cute? You know, nothing tastes as good as being thin feels - hey, Kate Moss said that, not me!" This was not a satisfactory retort, I was rather crestfallen that she has taken to quoting one of the fashion world's reknown cocaine-addled anorexic supermodel in order to support her own twisted self-image. I can't say she lost me as a fan, but she's lost this proud fat girl's hope for some comraderie in the lost days of post-riot grrl empowerment.

  • JLongen 09/07/2010 7:55:00 PM

    BOOOOO!! That article should have been called "Pointing Out Your Flaws, Seattle". I hope you don't get punched in YOUR shit-talking face! LOLmfao!!

  • KitKat 09/06/2010 2:23:00 PM

    First: I heard about the Bumbershoot Secret Show aka Witch hunt at 4:30 and opted not to go. They put her in a room full of Seattle Reporters, unplugged her and demanded that she sing in a small room. No, I'm not going to watch the flogging, thank you. I went to the mainstage show, and she tore it up. It was a wonderful show, and I'm glad I went to see her. Second: I loved Kurt; he was a great musician, but even worse off than Courtney. He shot himself. Get over it. We may make fun of Courtney's battles with sobriety, but at least she got sober. He never did - a lot of the great ones never did. The oversights in Kurt's will...that would be Kurt's fault. Guys, his lack of preparation left them in shambles, just like many of the greats have been known to do with the ones that were masochistic enough to love them. Face it - Courtney was the only one who could handle him because he was a hot crazy mess and vice versa. That's why they were perfect. Third: Look, I'm not from here. I moved here 13 years ago, and I do love it here; however, I must say you're a pretty bitter group of people. On the day-to-day, you're cordial and you seem to care, but once you get an idea in your jaws, you will sling it apart like a rag doll and not let it go. I can't figure out the ambition thing. There's just something in the air here that sucks the drive out of a person, and if someone says something like, "Wow. People just don't believe in showing up on time around here, do they?" There's a furious reaction. Can we talk about sobriety for a second? I've never met more people in my life that do nothing but drink as their 'hobby'. Mountains, lakes, and rivers...Saturday is bar time. ?? And I've never lived in a place of people that will make fun of you for not being a drinker. I realized the other day that 90% of my friends are not from here originally. It's odd, and I don't know how this silently happened, but it's as if you want the rest of the country to go away and leave you alone with your mountains. Then you get upset because you're lonely. Misery loves company, but why all of the misery? It's beautiful here, Natives. Love your lives.

  • engine13 09/06/2010 12:09:00 PM

    I was at bumpershoot (YAWN) long ride home. Cornie was drunk as a skunk falling off her stool and rambling like a psycho biotch pre concert stage. She is an unworthy has been and soooooo passe. I wish she would just crawl back into her hole! She was a problematic kid from the get go. Why is it all her other family members are normal and quite successful!? bGive the poor Cornie, BOOHOO a rest! She is a product of her self, PERIOD!

  • luckywonder 09/06/2010 12:02:00 PM

    Courtney is a crock of poo, and LA and NY know it better than anyone! Quit trashing Seattle and the surrounding communities! We are known for calling out pretentious crappers like Courtney. We are not 'haters", we see beyond the hype and BS!

  • Dan 09/06/2010 1:22:00 AM

    GREAT article. I lived in Seattle from 90-95 & I have to say, the Northwest is filled with haters. All the hate Courtney musters has a lot to do with the fact that Kurt was with HER- people tend to worship celebrity and want stars all for themselves. Hence, the Yoko effect, Courtney suffers from this greatly- especially in this passive-agressive, bitter, Northwest. Everyone is too cool for school here and are like sheep with their beliefs, I'm speaking of the haters of course. There are great people also in the Northwest, just needles in haystacks....

  • Litsa Dremousis 09/05/2010 9:15:00 PM

    Spot on about all it, Ma'chell. Really enjoyed this.

  • David 09/04/2010 12:04:00 AM

    In paragraph 2, on your list of reasons to hate her, which is already extensive, I do believe you left out a big one: many people believe she murdered Kurt Cobain.

  • OlsonBW 09/03/2010 9:42:00 PM

    I'm a man but I totally agree with you about Seattle's attitude about Courtney Love. You can not like or love the mess her life has been but that doesn't mean you have to hate the person. She's just dealing with life the only way that she has been able since she hasn't had another way that worked. Meaning, the emotional wounds from her childhood are not easily healed. Not wanting to be tortured by them anymore she turned to drugs because it would her only way of coping. I do hope she finds a better way without getting boring.

 

Most Popular Stories

Find a Concert


Now Click This

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy