Top

news

Stories

 

One Man, 26 Years, 112 Convictions

What sort of system allows a drug dealer to walk in and out of prison and get convicted more than 100 times? Ours.

Smooth is on the phone. "I've been charging $750," he tells his customer one day in 2007. "You know, I just give you a deal... my prices [between] me and you don't be the same prices to everybody else."

Jersey, his customer, listens. "I've been getting $250 a quarter [ounce]," Smooth says over his cell. "Two a quarter, you know." Jersey, a police informant, agrees to meet up, handing the phone back to a Seattle vice detective.

And Smooth is busted for drugs again.

In a word, busted is the life story of Stacy Earl Stith, street name Smooth. He's been caught a lot, often stumbling into the hands of police. In 1996, when a prostitute at Seventh and Bell asked what he was doing, Smooth said, "Selling, man!"—and pulled a cache of rocks from his pants pocket. "I sell to everyone!" The undercover police hooker beckoned her backup team, and Smooth went to jail.

In 2006, plainclothes cops were nabbing another dealer when Smooth and his girlfriend made two drug sales practically in front of them in City Hall Park, next to the King County Courthouse, where he'd already been convicted of nine felonies. He was arrested and went to jail only hours after he had been released from prison that same day.

According to court records and interviews, catching him wasn't complicated. He was mostly a street dealer—a cop's easy quota—distributing his stones, as he calls crack cocaine, hand to hand from Belltown to SoDo or by vehicle to home-delivery customers in the 'burbs. At times he stowed the tiny bags of stones in his car's or van's engine compartment, from where, an informant told police, the bags would occasionally drop onto the street, requiring Smooth to hop out and run back through traffic to retrieve them. Other times he'd spread the stash around: In a 2004 bust, cops found more than 15 grams of marijuana separated into 16 different bags in Smooth's pants pocket, 27 grams of marijuana and nine grams of crack in the trunk of his vehicle, 11 grams of crack in bags tucked into his waistband, and 49 grams of bagged crack in his underwear.

A 230-pound black man, his braided hair often dangling from under a sideways ball cap, Smooth has been relentlessly, if ineptly, selling and using drugs in Seattle for more than 25 years. Along the way, he's compiled a criminal record that's something of a record itself, authorities say: Adding up misdemeanors and felonies since the mid-1980s, he has 112 convictions. Not arrests, convictions: 94 misdemeanors and 18 felonies, revolving through the doors of juvenile court to municipal court to district court to superior court to federal court, from traffic and theft offenses and weapons and assault charges to burglary and crack sales. His first day in court was at age 13; his most recent, in January, at age 39.

"I have never seen anyone with this number of convictions around here," says 12-year King County deputy prosecutor Andy Colasurdo, who couldn't think of another violator who even came close. Some had a similar number of felonies, but "most of them only had 20 to 40 misdemeanors."

For all those convictions, Smooth has served an aggregate 14 years behind bars in local jails and state prisons, by Colasurdo's count. He had been sentenced to considerably more time, but his terms typically ran concurrently and he was usually released early. So he's had to work fast, scoring those 112 convictions in just 11 years of freedom. That's an average of 10 guilty verdicts per year.

"He," by the way, could mean Stacy Stith—or James Howard or Cal Beaver or Eric Smith, among others. Smooth has used 18 aliases, five dates of birth, and four Social Security numbers. It's possible, given that older court documents are often incomplete and crimes could be recorded under some of those aliases, Smooth's record may be even longer.

On the street, beat cops would recognize him on sight and assume he was in violation of something—parole, work release, curfew, loitering; most likely there was an arrest warrant somewhere with his name on it. (Court records show he had been sought on 52 warrants over two decades for a variety of crimes and failures to appear in court.)

Smooth was a sometimes hapless lawbreaker. One early-morning call brought officers to a smashed display window at the downtown Bon Marché, where they found him standing nearby with a pile of stolen clothes at his feet, department store tags flapping in the wind. But he was no comic figure. In 1999, he sped away from a police stop and careened around Central District corners in his '85 Buick. The chase ended when he slid sideways to a stop, tossed a loaded 40-caliber Glock out a window, and bailed. An officer pinned him down, but needed backup help to get him into handcuffs. Smooth was later convicted of being an armed felon.

He also has six convictions for resisting or obstructing police officers. In South King County in 2004, holding $1,300 in powder and rock cocaine, Smooth had to be Tasered four times before two cops could cuff him. Court records describe him as "a high-risk offender who presents a significant threat to the community."

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next Page >>
 
  • HangemHigh 07/23/2009 1:06:00 AM

    The POINT--other than the one atop your heads--is that crime is not punished here thus criminals among us do crimes with impunity. And yes, I would definitely support a 100 strikes you're out law.

  • Hugo 07/16/2009 3:10:00 AM

    How about a 100 strikes and you're out law? HAHA

  • Jenna 06/28/2009 6:51:00 AM

    I think I was most bothered by Smooth's background, particularly that he began using drugs at age 12. "Tough love" at that age would have been mandatory rehabilitation, but apparently neither his family nor the system knew or cared enough to attack the disease of his addiction at its root. I do not believe that drug addiction excuses the misbehavior of adults, but I do think that such early drug use should be factored into any judgment about Smooth's difficulties in kicking the habit and going clean. I heard that Portugal's decriminalization (substituting voluntary treatment for punitive state actions against drug users) is actually reducing drug use in their country. Maybe we should try something similar to prevent people like Smooth from throwing away their lives while still in middle school.

  • Tyrus 06/21/2009 12:49:00 AM

    I still don't see how this happened, other than everyone went along to get along. Why was it not until his 105th crime or whatever that they went to federal court? Wouldn't 50 had been a tipoff where he was headed?

  • Myk 06/16/2009 12:42:00 AM

    David, I think you missed the part with 112 convictions nearly all for drug/crack offenses. The orange shirt in this case fits...well like a T. I'm not a racist but if it walks like a dealer, talks on the phone like a dealer.. you know the drill. Maybe they should have dolled him up like Biggie Smalls and all that?

  • blake 06/15/2009 8:16:00 AM

    it seems he aint sssssssssssssssssssssso smooth

  • David English 06/15/2009 5:54:00 AM

    What,s with the black dope dealer wearing a loud orange shirt on the cover? I have been here five month,s and the racist images of blacks in this city is very negative and sick!

  • Lawful 06/13/2009 8:27:00 PM

    It makes you wonder, or rather, boggle: At what point should we stop blaming the system and start blaming the criminal? Twentieth conviction, 30th, 50th...90th...? After ten guilty verdicts, say, wouldn't you'd start to, uh, notice a pattern?

  • midtownmiscreant.blogspot.com 06/12/2009 9:36:00 PM

    Good article. My guess is Smooth gained so many convictions but did so little time for the reasons you listed, but also because he was probably trading information for reduced sentences. Ive known a lot of guys like Smooth, did time with them, knew them on the street. They sling dope and then blame it on society, racial disparity, addiction. These may be factors, but the main reason he kept doing what he was doing, is because he enjoyed it. He chose to sell dope, and it has finally caught up to him. He isnt a victim, he is a criminal. Paying a high price for his chosen occupation is part of the package.

  • Hugh Russell 06/11/2009 11:46:00 PM

    I think you get a good measure of Smooth here. The story makes clear he's an addict, and while the system failed to do its part, he most of all failed himself. Even his own attorney says he should have done more time. The story's underlying point is clear: life consists of the choices you make, and this guy, while he may not have chosen to be an addict, chose to stay one.

  • M.Marie 06/11/2009 11:02:00 PM

    What's the point? Prison is not the place for drug addicts? The inequities built into the legal system? Early intervention at the school and juvenile level vs. jail, prison and a wasted life? Addiction is so powerful that family, prison or a heart attack can't compete?

  • Taryn 06/11/2009 8:44:00 AM

    To Scott- Co-sign! Really, what was the point? I really love the front page and the graphics (side eye) BIG FAIL.

  • Scott Carter-Eldred 06/11/2009 4:32:00 AM

    What is the point of this article? To single out a guy who has obviously made a lot of bad decisions and hold him up to public ridicule? If this is a comment on the system, what's the comment? Do you honestly think the system failed by not putting him in prison for longer stretches? What would that have accomplished, exactly? You can't take the measure of a man just by looking at court documents and talking to lawyers. But those are the only sources for this ultimately mean-spirited article. I expect better from the Weekly and the often thoughtful Mr. Anderson.

  • MM 06/10/2009 10:50:00 PM

    They did him the favor one of his attorneys said they should have done for him a long time ago - gave him a good hard stretch in prison. He'll be an older and hopefully wiser guy this time out. Still, 112 convictions...don't judges look at records anymore?!

  • Art 06/10/2009 10:05:00 PM

    112 convictions and they still give him a break? Be ready for 113 when he gets out!

 

Most Popular Stories


Now Click This

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy