Seattle's E-Waste Conundrum

By Jan. 1 of 2009, consumers will have purchased thousands more thin-panel TVs and monitors, replacing cathode-ray tubes no one will want. In the interim, it's unlawful to dump those CRTs in the trash, and Seattle Public Utilities has no facility for recycling them. In 2009, broadcasters will shift from analog to digital signals, creating a kind of e-Day crisis.

Currently, the King County Solid Waste Division's "Take It Back Network" Web site lists around 30 collectors for e-debris. Most charge fees based on weight or screen size. Prices for drop-off typically range from $10 to $50—more for collectors to come to your home. These outfits then report their data to the county, which for 2006 tallied some 34,000 computers, 10,000 TVs, and 50,000 discarded monitors.

Why do monitors so outnumber TVs on the recycling market? Shorter product cycles and lower costs mean "you get a lot more corporate upgrades," says Steve Hess of RE-PC, which harvested 13,000 monitors in the first three quarters of last year. He guesses that 60 percent still come from individuals, most of them also upgrading to flat-panel displays. He adds, "The majority of monitors that come to us for recycling still work, probably two-thirds of them. But there's no market." He estimates that if the company—which specializes in refurbishment and resale—receives 1,500 monitors in a month, only 30 to 40 will leave the store with a dangling price tag. The rest go to a larger commodity recycler, which charges a disposal fee to RE-PC and other collectors. Industrial crushing and extracting then follow.

While Hess, who often has virtually new machines on his vast SoDo sales floor, would like for recyclers to become shoppers, he says, "We've found that doesn't necessarily happen." Being one of King County's designated e-waste collection points means exactly that: People drive up with their old CRT, pay the fee, and drive away. But when the new law goes into effect, RE-PC and other collectors will lose recycling fees—since the WMMFA will essentially take over the collection biz, presumably with large drop-off stations and curbside service using city trucks. For that reason, Hess and others complain that the program will favor the HPs and Dells of this world, who will gain control of both ends of the product life cycle.

The churn rate of TVs may be catching up with that of monitors, per King County data. Comparing the aggregate first three quarters of 2006 to 2007, monitor recycling is up 24 percent while TV recycling up 296 percent, which indicates that even in advance of the broadcast shift to high-def, local consumers are finding the price points they like for flat screens at Fry's and on Amazon.com. It's the buildup to e-Day, in other words, with more dead soldiers to come.

Caught between the changes in county and state law, waiting for amnesty, there's an untold number of old TV sets lurking in people's basements and attics. Seattle Public Utilities spokesperson Dick Lilly cites a 2003 report commissioned by SPU that concluded, "Seattle residents are already storing an estimated 223,000 obsolete computers, computer monitors, and televisions," amounting to more than 3,500 tons. That's equal in weight to the whole state's recycling achieved in that category in 2003, using state weight estimates.

Moreover, says Lilly, notwith-standing the occasional derelict Toshiba in the alley, the city hasn't encountered much illegal e-dumping. "It's hard to squeeze a 32-inch TV into your trash can," he notes.

Nationally, the Consumer Electronics Association estimates a recycling rate of 16 percent for "unwanted" TVs, and 14 percent for monitors. The rest are resold, donated, or dumped. But that CEA study dates to 2005, before states began changing the laws to prevent dumping.

If you extrapolate from Washington state and U.S. Census estimates, King County has about 1.7 million TVs and 2.1 million computers in use. Combine the CEA's rates for recycling and dumping, and the target numbers look like 612,000 TVs and 693,000 monitors. (That's 30,000 tons by Department of Ecology math, more than twice the volume collected statewide in 2006.) Meanwhile, new sales and ownership rates keep creeping upward, and 100 percent of everything eventually becomes obsolete.